A review of the best shoe covers for cycling The warmest waterproof winter overshoes for MTB, road cycling, bike-commuting, cycle touring, & bikepacking
Tired of your feet getting wet and cold, looking for the best cycling overshoes for your needs? You’re in the right place.
In this article, we compiled a list of the best waterproof and winter shoe cover for MTB, road cycling, everyday bike-commuting, cycle touring, and bikepacking.
Some of these products are the warmest overshoes available, some have outstanding waterproofness, some other excel for their versatility.
Although most overshoes for cycling are only meant for on-pedals use, because of their very thin or non-existent soles, here we featured some models that can actually be used for any discipline, even for tough hikes.
So, let’s dive into the comparison of the best cycling overshoes, updated for 2022!
12 best cycling overshoes in a nutshell
Disclosure: Some of our articles contain affiliate links. This comes at no additional cost for you and helps us keep this website up and running. (as Amazon Associates we earn commission from qualifying purchases)
4 Best road cycling shoe covers
C5 Gore Windstopper Thermo Overshoes
Castelli Estremo Shoe Cover
VeloToze Tall Road Cycling Shoe Cover
SHIMANO S-Phyre Insulated Shoe Cover
3 Best MTB overshoes
PEARL IZUMI Pro Barrier WxB MTB
GIRO Proof MTB Winter
ENDURA MT500 Plus Overshoe II
4 Best Commuting & Cycle Touring Shoe Covers
MAVIC Essential Thermo
Shower Pass Club Shoes Covers
VAUDE Bike Gaiter Long Waterproof
USHTH Waterproof Rain Boot
Bonus Product: the ultimate cycle touring winter boots
Louis Garneau Mudstone Cycling Shoe
4 best road cycling shoe covers
Road cycling overshoes are meant to be worn over cycling cleat shoes, most of these won’t work with flat pedals. They have a very thin sole with a hole for clipping-on, do not try to walk with them on as you’ll instantly damage them.
The fit of road cycling shoe covers is very tight, there’s no way those could fit over regular shoes or even hybrid cycle touring shoes, so buy these only if you’re going to use them with the proper footwear.
[membrane/laminate] GORE-TEX Infinium, [face fabric] Polartec Power Stretch Pro
YKK AquaGuard zipper
With the Estremo Shoe Cover, Castelli’s aim was to achieve the warmest cycling overshoe ever, and we can say they shoot right on target. If you ride in extremely cold conditions, even several degrees below freezing, the Castelli Estremo are the best shoe covers for you.
For the windproofing, they went with GORE-TEX INFINIUM™ WINDSTOPPER® fleece-backed fabric, highly breathable. A second fleece layer with Polartec® Power Stretch® Pro™ is added for unmatched insulation.
The boot is tall for extra warmth and splash protection, the zippers are waterproof and the wall construction can withstand constant rain for a while, even without being 100% waterproof. The Castelli Estremo overshoes are able to keep you warm down to -10°-5°C / 8°-41°F.
Shimano knows how to make footwear, among their several overshoes models, we decided to feature the S-Phyre Insulated Shoe Cover.
They are incredibly sturdy waterproof cycling boots, entirely made of thick (3mm) neoprene, they have no zippers or such. You have to slide in your cycling shoe for the tightest fit possible, this way water won’t leak in from the upper cuff, but you’ll have to struggle a bit when putting these on and taking them off.
Shoe covers designed for MTB use must be compatible with flat pedals and most kinds of sports shoes. They also need to be more resistant to thorns and rocks, mountain biking puts a lot of strain into gear. Some of these are also cleat-compatible.
High-quality cycling overshoes for flat pedals still come in limited options, and those specifically developed for MTB are even less.
Luckily, Pearl Izumi has all of ass avid mountain bikers covered with these Pro Barrier WxB MTB Shoe Cover.
The PRO Barrier WxB MTB overshoes are designed with adventure in mind, fat bike lovers and plus-addict can now tackle mud and snow without getting wet and cold feet.
All potential leaking points are eliminated by taped seams, making them totally waterproof, albeit still breathable. A fleece layer insulates under the outer shell, making those shoe covers suitable for freezing rides in the 30s and below.
The trail-specific soles grip well on the pedals and the KEVLAR reinforcement protects against trail abuse. Among the best MTB shoe covers on the market.
Another effective MTB overshoe option comes from Giro. The Proof MTB Winter Shoe Covers are made of water-resistant and wind-stopping stretch neoprene providing optimal warmth in mild winters while including flex zones in key areas to minimize bulk.
The soles feature a molded rubber bottom reinforcement, improving traction and durability, the toe area is also reinforced and padded for extra insulation and sturdiness.
The leak-proof locking-zipper closure ensures a proper fit, you can wear it easily over your mountain bike shoes without having to spend a good quarter of an hour trying to slip your feet in.
A small drawback is that the heel-cover surface isn’t grippy enough and might slip down if you’re not careful.
The Mavic Essential Thermo Overshoes are a great choice for those who tour with cleat shoes, they have all the characteristics of road cycling overshoes minus the tight fit, thus making them suitable to be worn also on clipless touring boots like these.
They are incredibly warm, able to keep you comfortable in subfreezing temperatures. Their closure is a combination of side zipper and hook-and-loop, a solution that makes it incredibly easy to slip in or take them off, while still ensuring reliable water protection.
For those who need a cleat-compatible shoe cover that could double as an everyday commuting overshoe and also perform well on a rough cycle trip, Shower Pass has sorted it out for you.
Showers Pass knows how to make their stuff waterproof, those cheap cycling overshoes will fulfill their purpose without the glitter of other brands, but for a cheaper price and with unmatched versatility.
The Club Shoe Cover can be worn over your sneakers, boots, cycling shoes, or even on fancy leather shoes in case you’re cycling to a formal meeting on a rainy day.
From legendary German brand, Vaude here come some of the best overshoes for bike touring and commuting.
The Vaude overshoes are among the tallest in this list, protecting your feet up over the calves. These waterproof gaiters are not just useful for riding, they also work great as hiking boots cover to bring on your wettest trekkings, a big advantage in versatility for those who travel on their bike.
There are no soles at all though, so water could sneak in from the bottom of the shoes you’ve under do not have leak-proof soles.
This product is made with Eco Finish, an environmentally friendly water-repellent fabric without fluorocarbons (PFC). The sandwich construction consists of technical outer material and a warming inner fleece.
mountain bike, bikepacking, fat biking, cycle touring
If you are looking for an all-in-one solution to ride safely and comfortably in any kind of weather, the Garneau’s Mudstone cycling boots are totally worth a look.
They are super-cool cleat-compatible cycling boots that can be totally used off the bike for any kind of trekking or walk around.
Comfortable, warm, totally water-proof, BOA adjustable closure, soft ankle for comfort when walking, these could easily be your only pair of shoes needed for your cycling trip to North Cape or Patagonia. They provide great traction on and off the bike and are incredibly durable.